Posted July 14, 2014 Wow, great idea! Maybe if TJ see which ones do well, he'll use them. Or if he's haveing trouble picking, he'll be able to check and see which ones WE like more and use that one! (I can dream!) Acorn VS Aero (they look so shiny and clean!) Akuma VS Alabaster Ambrosial VS Amour Propre (I love all the colours!) Anathema Dragon VS Ancient Luminescent Angelfish VS Antarean Aposematic Water VS Apple Mints (both varieties) Aquamarine Dino VS Archipelago (I don't like dinos and unbreedables) Arctic Bat VS Arctic Fox (so fluffy!) Argent Bat VS Argon (I like them both, but the bat needs an update) Armoured Western VS Artistic Assassino VS Auroral Flareback (eastern!) Austral VS Azure NULL I don't really like either much Azure Glacewing VS Backflip Banana Pygmy VS Bane Barb-TailedVS Battle Bear VS Bichir Biped VS Black Capped Black Dino VS Black Ray Lindwurm (Yay lindwurms!) Black Shuck VS Black Tri Blackphase VS Blade Blazeback VS Blind NULL I don't really like either much Bloom VS Blossom Angels Blue Rose VS Blue Screecher (Weee hybrid!) Blue Tongue VS Blue-Streaked Bluver Pygmy VS Bog Lich Boreal VS Briar Brown Dino VS Bubble Bull Wyvern VS Bulwark I don't like either, but the face shading on the bull looks so weird... Butcher VS Cactus Pygmy Caldera VS Calligraphy Caped VS Cascade Dancer Catkin VS Celestial Imitators Cerise-Winged VS Chameleon Channel-Light Dragonet VS Charcoal I'm neutral on the charcoals, but the breeding with dragons and drakes seems really silly to me. Charred VS Cherry (these ones are one of my favorites on the whole list) Chi-Wing VS Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere VS Chocolate Tipped Cielarch VS Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern VS Cleaner Pygmy Cliffhopper VS Colibri Comet Amphiptere VS Common Coral VS Coral Reef Corn Wyrm VS Corrosive Spitter Cowardly VS Crawler Pygmy Crescent-Tailed Moonflier VS Crystal Song Cyan VS Daedalean Dancing VS Dark Weaver (I love how wolfy the faces are) Darkwing VS Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer VS Deep Cave The shading seems super weird on the deathbringers Share this post Link to post
Posted July 14, 2014 Acorn VS Aero (always liked the style of the Aero) Akuma VS Alabaster (akuma's wings look small :/) Ambrosial VS Amour Propre (neat color scheme on the amour. The Ambrosial alts hurt my eyes :/) Anathema Dragon VS Ancient Luminescent (both are cool but the anathema looks like nothing we have now) Angelfish VS Antarean (Love the narrow face and the angel fish always looked blocky to me) Aposematic Water VS Apple Mints (both varieties) (Hard choice but the color schemes on the Aposematics won out) Aquamarine Dino VS Archipelago (We may need more dinos but I can't say no to that dragon) Arctic Bat VS Arctic Fox (Would have nulled except for the fact the bats look similar to another (not sure which) games style.) Argent Bat VS Argon (The Argon's tail makes the body look deformed, not enough clear definition between them to my eyes.) Armoured Western VS Artistic (NULL: The Armoured western seems to use a lot of colors without being crazy and the artistic looks playful and ready to paint the world) Assassino VS Auroral Flareback (I like glowy things.) Austral VS Azure (Australs differ too much) Azure Glacewing VS Backflip (Null: playfulness and pretty scales can't really compete) Banana Pygmy VS Bane (Too cute) Barb-Tailed VS Battle (Null: Too really nice dragons want both) Bear VS Bichir (Bichir though this was a hard pic) Biped VS Black Capped (looks cute and the biped was never my cup of tea) Black Dino VS Black Ray Lindwurm (Pretty <3) Black Shuck VS Black Tri (Null far too pretty for both) Blackphase VS Blade (Just favor them) Blazeback VS Blind (I like the fire) Bloom VS Blossom Angels (I love these guys) Blue Rose VS Blue Screecher (null too pretty) Blue Tongue VS Blue-Streaked (reminds me of skinks) Bluver Pygmy VS Bog Lich (just too cool) Boreal VS Briar (Never really liked the Brairs) Brown Dino VS Bubble (so playful) Bull Wyvern VS Bulwark (Slight art style preferences) Butcher VS Cactus Pygmy (I saw these being done ad I love them) Caldera VS Calligraphy (I love how expressive they are) Caped VS Cascade Dancer (I'm a sucker for those wings) Catkin VS Celestial Imitators (Tough call) Cerise-Winged VS Chameleon (They look curious) Channel-Light Dragonet VS Charcoal (Channel lights are really hard to see with the other colored backgrouds behind them) Charred VS Cherry (another hard choice, charred seem too skinny for me) Chi-Wing VS Chickadee Pygmy (there wings are too cute) Chimeric Amphiptere VS Chocolate Tipped (they just jumped out at me) Cielarch VS Cinderwing Amphithere (if the cinderwing had been a pygmy amphithere it would have swung my vote) Citrus Wyvern VS Cleaner Pygmy (Null: I've wanted the Cleaners since for ever but the Citrus would look so good with the flamingo I can't vote against it) Cliffhopper VS Colibri (as much as I adore thuban and her concept the Colibri's won with color scheme and playfullness) Comet Amphiptere VS Common (Because we need a dragon as common, and we already have blue flames quite recently) Coral VS Coral Reef (Can't get into the Coral Reef's look) Corn Wyrm VS Corrosive Spitter (Its so cute and tiny and looks like a rattle snake O3O) Cowardly VS Crawler Pygmy (Inch worm love ) Crescent-Tailed Moonflier VS Crystal Song (Bright Colors won this time) Cyan VS Daedalean (Again I like cool colors, though the Daedalean is cool too) Dancing VS Dark Weaver (The weaver has fire and the dancing wings look wierd) Darkwing VS Dazzeltail Dragon (I love the wings and the tail) Deathbringer VS Deep Cave (just a cool sprite.) Share this post Link to post
Posted July 15, 2014 Well, to be fair I'm part of the community too. I'd like to avoid ones separated by a view votes getting 'pardoned' as that will really add to how long it will take, especially in the last rounds where things get more heated as the breeds that remain are the site favourites. However, in a true tie I don't mind passing both if that's what you guys would really rather see. It probably won't happen a lot, so it won't make as much of a difference. I forgot that you were. Sorry about that. I blame my lack of sleep at the time. As for the pardoning, I understand what you are saying. I just mentioned the range because there are roughly 30 votes at the moment and a 2 vote difference doesn't seem like much. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 15, 2014 Oh, wow! This is such an awesome idea! And it should help TJ figure out which sprites he might release earlier! I hope the Zmey is in the final Top Ten, I think that's my ultimate favorite. My votes: Aero Alabaster Amor Propre Ancient Luminescent Antarean Aposematic Water Archipelago Arctic Fox Argent Bat/Argon = Not keen on either Armoured Western Auroral Flareback Azure Azure Glacewing Bane Battle Bichir Black-capped Black Dino Black Tri Blackphase/Blade = COULDN'T DECIDE Blazeback Bloom Blue Screecher Blue-Streaked Bog lich Briar Brown Dino Bull Wyvern Butcher Caldera Cascade Dancer Celestial imitator Cerise-winged Channel-light Dragonet Cherry Chi-winged Chocolate-tipped Cinderwing Ampitere Cleaner pygmy Colibri Comet Amphitere Coral Reef Corrosive spitter Cowardly/Crawler pygmy = Not keen on either Crystal song Daedalean Dark Weaver Dazzletail Deep Cave Share this post Link to post
Posted July 15, 2014 I just realized that once the next round rolls around, I feel like more people will vote for the Eves than my baby Erseliks. ;w; Oh well. To be fair, the Eves are quite pretty. But then, who knows, I might be surprised! I don't think I'm going to null my vote on anything, even my own dragons, just because. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 15, 2014 (edited) This seems like a great idea :3 Are we still voting on set one? Acorn Alabaster Amour Propre Anathema Dragon Angelfish Apple Mints Archipelago Arctic Fox Argon Artistic Assassino Austral Azure Glacewing Bane Battle Bichir Biped Black Ray Lindwurm Black Tri Blackphase Blazeback Blossom Angels Blue Rose Blue Tongue Bog Lich Briar Brown Dino Bulwark Butcher Calligraphy Cascade Dancer Catkin Chameleon Charcoal Charred Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern Cliffhopper Comet Amphiptere Coral Reef Corn Wyrm Crawler Pygmy Crystal Song Cyan Dark Weaver Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer Edited July 15, 2014 by StarLaDragon Share this post Link to post
Posted July 16, 2014 SET 1 Acorn VS Aero Akuma VS Alabaster Ambrosial VS Amour Propre - NULL Anathema Dragon VS Ancient Luminescent Angelfish VS Antarean Aposematic Water VS Apple Mints (both varieties) Aquamarine Dino VS Archipelago Arctic Bat VS Arctic Fox Argent Bat VS Argon Armoured Western VS Artistic Assassino VS Auroral Flareback Austral VS Azure Azure Glacewing VS Backflip Banana Pygmy VS Bane Barb-Tailed VS Battle Bear VS Bichir Biped VS Black Capped Black Dino VS Black Ray Lindwurm Black Shuck VS Black Tri Blackphase VS Blade Blazeback VS Blind Bloom VS Blossom Angels Blue Rose VS Blue Screecher Blue Tongue VS Blue-Streaked Bluver Pygmy VS Bog Lich Boreal VS Briar Brown Dino VS Bubble - NULL Bull Wyvern VS Bulwark Butcher VS Cactus Pygmy Caldera VS Calligraphy Caped VS Cascade Dancer Catkin VS Celestial Imitators Cerise-Winged VS Chameleon Channel-Light Dragonet VS Charcoal Charred VS Cherry Chi-Wing VS Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere VS Chocolate Tipped Cielarch VS Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern VS Cleaner Pygmy Cliffhopper VS Colibri Comet Amphiptere VS Common Coral VS Coral Reef Corn Wyrm VS Corrosive Spitter Cowardly VS Crawler Pygmy Crescent-Tailed Moonflier VS Crystal Song Cyan VS Daedalean Dancing VS Dark Weaver Darkwing VS Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer VS Deep Cave Lots of tough decisions here. Some pairs I didn't much like either one. More pairs that I really loved both, but finally forced myself to choose. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 16, 2014 Acorn VS Aero Akuma VS Alabaster Ambrosial VS Amour Propre Anathema Dragon VS Ancient Luminescent Angelfish VS Antarean Aposematic Water VS Apple Mints (both varieties) Aquamarine Dino VS Archipelago Arctic Bat VS Arctic Fox Argent Bat VS Argon Armoured Western VS Artistic Assassino VS Auroral Flareback Austral VS Azure Azure Glacewing VS Backflip Banana Pygmy VS Bane Barb-Tailed VS Battle Bear VS Bichir Biped VS Black Capped Black Dino VS Black Ray Lindwurm Black Shuck VS Black Tri Blackphase VS Blade Blazeback VS Blind Bloom VS Blossom Angels Blue Rose VS Blue Screecher Blue Tongue VS Blue-Streaked Bluver Pygmy VS Bog Lich Boreal VS Briar Brown Dino VS Bubble Bull Wyvern VS Bulwark Butcher VS Cactus Pygmy Caldera VS Calligraphy Caped VS Cascade Dancer Catkin VS Celestial Imitators Cerise-Winged VS Chameleon Channel-Light Dragonet VS Charcoal Charred VS Cherry Chi-Wing VS Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere VS Chocolate Tipped Cielarch VS Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern VS Cleaner Pygmy Cliffhopper VS Colibri Comet Amphiptere VS Common Coral VS Coral Reef Corn Wyrm VS Corrosive Spitter Cowardly VS Crawler Pygmy Crescent-Tailed Moonflier VS Crystal Song Cyan VS Daedalean Dancing VS Dark Weaver Darkwing VS Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer VS Deep Cave Share this post Link to post
Posted July 16, 2014 (edited) This is a really great idea! Acorn Alabaster Ambrosial Ancient Luminescent Antarean Aposematic Water Archipelago Arctic Fox Argent Bat Artistic Auroral Flareback Azure Azure Glacewing Banana Pygmy Barb-Tailed Bichir Black Capped Black Ray Lindwurm Black Shuck Blackphase Blind Blossom Angels Blue Rose Blue-Streaked Bog Lich Boreal Bubble Bulwark Cactus Pygmy Calligraphy Cascade Dancer Catkin - really tough choice! Chameleon Charcoal Cherry - really tough choice! Chi-Wing Chimeric Amphiptere Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern Cliffhopper Comet Amphiptere Coral Corn Wyrm Crawler Pygmy Crescent-Tailed Moonflier - tough choice! Cyan Dancing Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer Edited July 16, 2014 by Sany Share this post Link to post
Posted July 16, 2014 (edited) Acorn Alabaster Ambrosial Ancient Luminescent Antarean Aposematic Water Archipelago Arctic Fox Argon Artistic Assassino Austral Azure Glacewing Bane Barb-Tailed Bear Black Capped Black Ray Lindwurm Black Shuck Blade Blazeback Blossom Angels Blue Screecher Blue Tongue Bog Lich Boreal Bubble Bull Wyvern Cactus Pygmy Calligraphy Caped Catkin Chameleon Charcoal Cherry Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern Colibri Common Coral Corrosive Spitter Crawler Pygmy Crystal Song Cyan Dark Weaver Dazzeltail Dragon Deep Cave Edited July 16, 2014 by Niyaka Share this post Link to post
Posted July 17, 2014 Everything up to here has been recorded. Thank you! I forgot that you were. Sorry about that. I blame my lack of sleep at the time. As for the pardoning, I understand what you are saying. I just mentioned the range because there are roughly 30 votes at the moment and a 2 vote difference doesn't seem like much. That is a fair point, but at the same time some 5 or 6 breeds in just this set that would qualify right now, and more that could get into that territory with another vote or two. It it keeps up it at that pace could add 15+ to the first round alone. That may slow us down and this will already be a long tournament. I am happy that that's happening though. It's great to see that we have a range on opinions and that there aren't many landslide winners so far. Again, a big thanks to all voters. This seems like a great idea :3 Are we still voting on set one? Yes we are . Next set will be some time friday. Keep an eye out! Share this post Link to post
Posted July 17, 2014 This is really great idea! I was just wondering if Dinos shouldn't be excluded from the voting or get their own voting? Because everytime there was one I voted for the Dino and as they're aren't actual dragons, I think it's unfair to eliminate dragons because of them. But might be just me Acorn Alabaster Amour Propre Ancient Luminescent Antarean Aposematic Water Aquamarine Dino Arctic Bat Argent Bat Artistic Assassino Azure Azure Glacewing Banana Pygmy Battle Bear Biped Black Dino Black Tri Blackphase Blazeback Bloom Blue Rose Blue-Streaked Bog Lich Briar Brown Dino Bulwark Butcher Calligraphy Caped Celestial Imitators Chameleon Charcoal Cherry Chickadee Pygmy Chocolate Tipped Cinderwing Amphithere Cleaner Pygmy Cliffhopper Common Coral Corn Wyrm Cowardly Crescent-Tailed Moonflier Cyan Dancing Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer Share this post Link to post
Posted July 17, 2014 Aero Alabaster Ambrosial Ancient Luminescent Antarean Apple Mints (both varieties) Archipelago Arctic Bat Argon Artistic Auroral Flareback Azure Azure Glacewing Banana Pygmy Battle Bear Black Capped Black Ray Lindwurm Black Tri Blackphase Blazeback Blossom Angels Blue Rose Blue-Streaked Bluver Pygmy Boreal Bubble Bull Wyvern Butcher Calligraphy Cascade Dancer Catkin Cerise-Winged Charcoal Cherry Chickadee Pygmy Chocolate Tipped Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern Colibri Comet Amphiptere Coral Corn Wyrm Crawler Pygmy Crystal Song Cyan Dancing Dazzeltail Dragon Deep Cave Share this post Link to post
Posted July 17, 2014 Nice idea, thanks for organising! Winners in bold: Acorn VS Aero Akuma VS Alabaster Ambrosial VS Amour Propre Anathema Dragon VS Ancient Luminescent Angelfish VS Antarean Aposematic Water VS Apple Mints (both varieties) Aquamarine Dino VS Archipelago Arctic Bat VS Arctic Fox Argent Bat VS Argon Armoured Western VS Artistic Assassino VS Auroral Flareback Austral VS Azure Azure Glacewing VS Backflip Banana Pygmy VS Bane Barb-Tailed VS Battle Bear VS Bichir Biped VS Black Capped Black Dino VS Black Ray Lindwurm Black Shuck VS Black Tri Blackphase VS Blade Blazeback VS Blind Bloom VS Blossom Angels Blue Rose VS Blue Screecher Blue Tongue VS Blue-Streaked Bluver Pygmy VS Bog Lich BorealVS Briar Brown Dino VS Bubble Bull Wyvern VS Bulwark Butcher VS Cactus Pygmy Caldera VS Calligraphy Caped VS Cascade Dancer Catkin VS Celestial Imitators Cerise-Winged VS Chameleon Channel-Light Dragonet VS Charcoal Charred VS Cherry Chi-Wing VS Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere VS Chocolate Tipped Cielarch VS Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern VS Cleaner Pygmy Cliffhopper VS Colibri Comet Amphiptere VS Common Coral VS Coral Reef Corn Wyrm VS Corrosive Spitter Cowardly VS Crawler Pygmy Crescent-Tailed Moonflier VS Crystal Song Cyan VS Daedalean Dancing VS Dark Weaver Darkwing VS Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer VS Deep Cave Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 Alright, everything has been tallied for this round! Here are our winners for the first set! (winners in bold, eliminated crossed out) Acorn VS Aero Akuma VS Alabaster Ambrosial VS Amour Propre Anathema Dragon VS Ancient Luminescent Angelfish VS Antarean Aposematic Water VS Apple Mints Aquamarine Dino VS Archipelago Arctic Bat VS Arctic Fox Argent Bat VS Argon Armoured Western VS Artistic Assassino VS Auroral Flareback Austral VS Azure Azure Glacewing VS Backflip Banana Pygmy VS Bane Barb-Tailed VS Battle Bear VS Bichir Biped VS Black Capped Black Dino VS Black Ray Lindwurm Black Shuck VS Black Tri Blackphase VS Blade Blazeback VS Blind Bloom VS Blossom Angels Blue Rose VS Blue Screecher Blue Tongue VS Blue-Streaked Bluver Pygmy VS Bog Lich Boreal VS Briar Brown Dino VS Bubble Bull Wyvern VS Bulwark Butcher VS Cactus Pygmy Caldera VS Calligraphy Caped VS Cascade Dancer Catkin VS Celestial imitators - Our first tie ladies and gentlemen! So, I use my vote to pass the Celestial imitators. Cerise-Winged VS Chameleon Channel-Light Dragonet VS Charcoal Charred VS Cherry Chi-Wing VS Chickadee Pygmy Chimeric Amphiptere VS Chocolate Tipped Cielarch VS Cinderwing Amphithere Citrus Wyvern VS Cleaner Pygmy Cliffhopper VS Colibri Comet Amphiptere VS Common Coral VS Coral Reef Corn Wyrm VS Corrosive Spitter Cowardly VS Crawler Pygmy Crescent-Tailed Moonflier VS Crystal Song Cyan VS Daedalean Dancing VS Dark Weaver Darkwing VS Dazzeltail Dragon Deathbringer VS Deep Cave And now we are moving on to set 2! YAY! For the next round, Ponytales has graciously set up an off site poll for set 2. The vote will require your forum name to prevent cheating or accidental duplicates, so all you will have to do is post here once you do the vote so we can make sure every set of votes comes from an actual forum user. If it works well, we will do it for every round. If the poll doesn't work for you for any reason, you may post your votes in the thread just like set 1 and they will be manually entered in. Poll HERE! (Thanks to Ponytales for setting up!) Please make sure to POST that you did the poll! Once we move to the next set, I'll post the results page for everyone to see along with the winners. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 I just voted on the new poll (Thanks Ponytales ) for round two. Just want to add a note that I love all of the garden dragons so I could not pick one or the other when it came to those Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 Cactus Pygmies nooo ;___; </3 Oh man the next set looks super tough, already agonizing over the first set and a quick scroll through shows almost no easy choices! Wahhhhh! XAx *rips some of her votes from round one and gives to these guys* Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 I voted on the new poll for round 2. Some of these choices were hard and the pictures were sometimes hard to see for me but I got through it nonetheless. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 This was hard. But I voted for round 2. Just a note that there was the Ethereal Drake was either recently added to the completed list or overlooked. I'm guessing it was added just yesterday by the "edit time" at the end of the post, however all the posts on the completed list have the same date. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 (edited) This was hard. But I voted for round 2. Just a note that there was the Ethereal Drake was either recently added to the completed list or overlooked. I'm guessing it was added just yesterday by the "edit time" at the end of the post, however all the posts on the completed list have the same date. First post: The voting will be based on the list as it is at the time of the threads posting, so threads added, updated, or removed from the CL will not change the vote. If it wasn't on the completed list on Jul 11 it isn't going to be included and according to the last post they were moved to completed on the 17th. So, they weren't missed. Thank you for pointing it out though! EDIT: Also, angelicdragonpuppy you're votes aren't showing up. You may need to vote again. So far we have: lollipop00, Gingehfish, aqua17, xdlugia, and PonyTales Edited July 18, 2014 by aangs-sister Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 I voted, and I'm pretty sure the only one I nulled was the emrald eastern pygmy and the elemental wings (because I'm the conceptor of the emralds x.x) Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 I voted in the second set. Sad to see some of my favorites eliminated in the first round, but a lot of them got through all the same, so I'm not too disappointed. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 (edited) Just voted on set two! This is fun~ Edit: Just one question: Why wasn't the Ethereal Drake http://forums.dragcave.net/?showtopic=160174 on the list? It's so awesome ;_; Edited July 18, 2014 by Niyaka Share this post Link to post
Posted July 18, 2014 Just voted on set two! This is fun~ Edit: Just one question: Why wasn't the Ethereal Drake http://forums.dragcave.net/?showtopic=160174 on the list? It's so awesome ;_; The voting will be based on the list as it is at the time of the threads posting, so threads added, updated, or removed from the CL will not change the vote. If it wasn't on the completed list on Jul 11 it isn't going to be included and according to the last post they were moved to completed on the 17th. So, they weren't missed, they didn't make it in time to be included. Share this post Link to post
Posted July 19, 2014 I have voted on set 2. Some beautiful dragons there and some hard decisions. Share this post Link to post
Recommended Posts