Edit: TJ says he won't reconsider banning my scroll, and that I should stop bothering him. So thank you to all the people who tried to help me, but I guess I won't be breeding any eggs for anyone :(
I'll probably take this whole long thing down soon, but I'm leaving it up at least right now for anyone who wanted to know the outcome, and because I haven't yet decided what to put in its place.
-------Older content below this line------
My current project is to get my scroll restored. It was burned for "multiscrolling," which I did not do. TJ's own records will show that, but he is not reading the pm's I send him to explain that.
So I'm requesting as many people as possible to send TJ09 a pm, asking him to restore Nat's scroll.
If it's restored, I am offering to breed a BSA dragon for each person who asks me to. They will be mostly 2G purebreds, although I can do some 3G purebreds and some 2G with other-breed parents (CB holidays, for example). I have lots of orange (magi), red, and pink dragons, also some purple and white dragons to breed from.
Timeline of my scroll problem:
July 26, 2018 came home from a family vacation
August 3, my scroll (Nat) and my daughter's scroll (Vict) were burned
I assumed an error (caused by traveling together), and pm'd TJ.
August 18, I pm'd TJ again.
August 20, TJ responded:
"Your accounts were indeed identified as being multiple accounts, but no it was not wrongly so. There is clear evidence of egg funneling (i.e. many one-sided trades) that indicates that the accounts were being used primarily by one person, rather than by two people."
That is the entire text of TJ's response.
I sent him another pm at once, and about one each week since then, but he has not read any of them. (It's over a month now, since the only response he gave me.)
How can "many one-sided trades" be multi-scrolling?
TJ created teleport, the forums are full of gifting threads, and TJ has never posted any limits about using it.
Mutiple accounts in one household are explicitly permitted in the FAQ, "as long as each person sticks to their own scroll."
I only played my scroll, Vict only played her scroll.
Proof that we each played our own scroll includes:
Nat, me, was the one who sent teleports. I was also raising lots of dragons for myself (see list at the bottom of this page). I did not gift to Vict any of the "good" dragons (CB gold, CB silver, CB copper, 2G prize). They were either traded to others through the trading hub, or kept for myself. I also have a history of gifting dragons to other people: either I'm "multi-scrolling" with at least 4 people over many years, some of whom live a long ways away, or I'm an individual who sometimes gifts dragons (you know, with the feature TJ made.)
Vict, who received the trades, was also raising lots of other dragons at all times. She has remained consistently active, even when I (Nat) take breaks between new releases. Her being active when I'm not shows that she is a separate person playing her own scroll, not a secondary scroll of mine.
My scroll was started in 2008. Here's one of my oldest dragons:
Vict's scroll was started in 2012. Here's one of her dragons from that year:
If we have been separate people for all those years, how can we be one person now?
(C) TJ's own records:
If TJ logs the time of actions, he can see that Vict reliably does things earlier in the morning ("before school"), and Nat stays up much later at night. We are both active in the afternoons and weekends, while she's NOT active during school hours (but I am).
If TJ looks at the total number of actions, he can see that gifting from my scroll to hers was only a small part of the activity for each scroll, for any time that he may choose to examine.
If TJ looks at what actions happened on what days, he can see that I often take days and weeks off between releases/breeding projects, while Vict is more consistently active.
Vict and I use different computers, and are probably running different browser versions. If TJ records this info, it will show that my scroll is consistently access from one computer, hers from the other.
(D) Publicly available data:
Anyone can see that we name our dragons differently, at the Wayback Machine captures of our scrolls:
(That's mine from 2013 and Vict's from 2016. My dragons that say "Pauline's" or "Kristin's" are because I have a habit of letting young children choose names for my dragons, while they're too young for scrolls of their own. Vict tells me that her names are often based on the code of the dragon, which can be seen by mousing over the images on that captured page.)
Anyone can also see (get codes from the Wayback Machine, or see a list at the bottom of this) that I have lots of CB dragons and their 2G offspring, while she has lots of bred/lineaged dragons, most of which have parents that are NOT MINE. Clearly, she has a history of either trading or AP hunting. (I think it's mostly AP, at least until the trading hub was introduced.)
Anyone can see that we both post in the game thread, "How high can you count before a mod posts." (My user name and scroll are both Nat; hers are Vict.) Note that she's absent during "school hours" and late at night, while I post at any time.
Anyone can look at the dragons I recently raised (list at bottom of this) as proof that I was quite busy playing MY OWN SCROLL during the two months before it was burned. Each shows owner's name "Nat," and dates.
So please pm TJ for me, and if my scroll gets restored, pm me to breed you an egg. You can choose its parents, within reason (any common CB is fine. Rare-breed parents only as available.)
Lists of dragons I raised, bred, or froze since June 1, 2018.
These are to show how much not-gifting-to-Vict activity I did.
These lists are probably not complete (I was searching my browser history, and surely missed some.)
But every dragon listed belongs to me (owner: Nat), and every dragon listed either grew/froze on my scroll in the past few months, or I bred it to produce offspring in the past few months.
Adult dragons raised by Nat since the beginning of June 2018:
dragcave.net/view/WLtGv Carina, bred by me
dragcave.net/view/CYgZP CB Spring Seasonal
dragcave.net/view/cn1wv Spinel Wyvern, alt bred by me
dragcave.net/view/LFsm7 CB gold floret wyvern
Dragons I froze (each shows owner's name "Nat," and dates of stealing/breeding and hatching.)
I bred all of these, except the 4 labelled "CB"
dragcave.net/view/27g6O CB paper
dragcave.net/view/9GVNR CB dino
dragcave.net/view/a9VhO CB dino
dragcave.net/view/dTkFW CB dino
Dragons I bred, with offspring that are no longer on my scroll:
I have listed progeny pages of my own dragons, rather than directly listing dragons that belong to other people.
https://dragcave.net/progeny/Shiny CB prize: bred at least 5 times in June/July. Kept 1, traded/gifted/AP'd the rest.
https://dragcave.net/progeny/vn64 Bred a frill baby in June
https://dragcave.net/progeny/tgFg Bred 3 geode babies in June/July--1 now belongs to Vict, other 2 to others. (Wanted pebble, got geodes)
https://dragcave.net/progeny/fsrKt Bred 1 "wrong color" gemshard
https://dragcave.net/progeny/9WubT Bred 1 "wrong color" gemshard
https://dragcave.net/progeny/f7h8 Bred 1 summer seasonal--I think it was for a trade; certainly is not mine or Vict's now.
https://dragcave.net/progeny/LG1AR Seasonal: 1 for me, 1 other (trade/gift/AP-- cannot remember now)
https://dragcave.net/progeny/dkBj Seasonal: 1 for me, 1 other
https://dragcave.net/progeny/6dWl Seasonal: 1 for me, 2 others
https://dragcave.net/progeny/pAYnM Lumina: was trying for dark, got light
https://dragcave.net/progeny/DXbg Ice: 1 for me, 1 for someone else
https://dragcave.net/progeny/pKzny Bred 1 "wrong color" gemshard
https://dragcave.net/progeny/OE70 Bred 2 "wrong color" dorsals
https://dragcave.net/progeny/nnqvO Bred 1 nebula and 2 5G prizes for others
https://dragcave.net/progeny/hLLor Bred a silver for someone else
https://dragcave.net/progeny/DdXUv Bred 3G prize, for 3 different people
https://dragcave.net/progeny/HZ96G Bred 3, for 3 different people (2 silvers, 1 royal blue)
https://dragcave.net/progeny/le1YW 1 wrong-color stripe for someone else (several "right" ones for me)
https://dragcave.net/progeny/XFek9 "Wrong color" stripes: 1 to Vict, 2 to others
https://dragcave.net/progeny/eNm4 3 "wrong color" stripes in 2018: 2 to Vict, 1 to someone else.
https://dragcave.net/progeny/UFvBt 1 "wrong color" stripe to someone
https://dragcave.net/progeny/Vk8YF 2 "wrong color" stripes in 2018: 1 to Vict, 1 to someone else
https://dragcave.net/progeny/03mCK 1 "wrong color" stripe to someone
https://dragcave.net/progeny/RuJPe Bred 2 stripes: 1 for me, 1 for someone else
https://dragcave.net/progeny/fHyLm Bred 2 stripes: 1 for me, 1 for someone else
https://dragcave.net/progeny/HISY summer seasonal from 2 autumns
https://dragcave.net/progeny/YvXV summer seasonal from 2 autumns
https://dragcave.net/progeny/c7Fq summer seasonal from 2 autumns
https://dragcave.net/progeny/ucVK0 Gemshard: 1 for me, 1 for someone else
https://dragcave.net/progeny/TCFZ Nebula to AP, Carina for me
https://dragcave.net/progeny/bskD Nebula to AP, Carina for me
BSA dragons that I bred in June/July (most the offspring found homes through the AP; I labelled any whose babies are now mine or Vict's)