Posted May 16, 2015 Name: 8/10 Nice and simple, no numbers and properly capitalized Avatar: 9/10 not sure what it is, but it's cute and it moves, and it's high quality Siggy: 7/10 the "win a gold dragon" thing is hilarious, but I don't get the huge anime girl Share this post Link to post
Posted May 16, 2015 Name: 8/10 very nicely done Avatar: 7/10 not sure what is with the tree and dragon but still i like the picture nonetheless Sig: 8/10 as i love the candle in the center of the sig Share this post Link to post
Posted May 17, 2015 Name: 9/10 I prefer no numbers Avatar: 8/10 Sig: 9/10 very simple and neat but looks a little empty Share this post Link to post
Posted May 19, 2015 Name: 8.5/10 Very clean and well done, but not very obvious Avatar: 9/10 hilarious screen cap Sig: 6/10 bare links and no formatting, but not messy Share this post Link to post
Posted May 19, 2015 (edited) Name: 9.8/10 Avatar: 9/10 Sig: 9.9/10 Edited May 19, 2015 by bigbite100 Share this post Link to post
Posted June 18, 2015 Name: 4/10 Seems a little drab to me Avatar: 5/10 a White on a rock doesn't grab my attention Sig: 7/10 Nice words =3 Share this post Link to post
Posted June 18, 2015 Ima gonna go hard on you Name: 6/10 Avatar: 4/10 because it's blocked so all I can see is a pixelated mess that loosely resembles a wolf Sig: 7/10 including the fact that your picture is blocked so I can see a pixelated mess that loosely resembles a mountain But most of the points go to that inspirational quote you have over there Share this post Link to post
Posted August 20, 2015 Name: 10/10 Avatar: 7/10 Siggy: 2/10 Please explain ratings ~ Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 Name: 10/10 No numbers, capitalized, awesome! Avatar: 9/10 Bit hard to see the image details, but overall very nice. Siggy: 5/10 Just text and it isn't centered Please explain ratings~ Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 Name: 9.8/10 Pretty good. Avatar: 10/10 would look at again. Signature: 10/10 for that sweet, sweet gif. Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 Name 9/10 No fan of no spacing or no space substitutions, but I like Pokémon. Avatar 5/10 Reminds me of my horible old sprites, and I honestly believe it can be made much nicer as well. But Pokémon. Signature 8/10? I don't really kniw what to say here, sorry. Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 Name: 7.5/10 Pretty good, but not really my taste. I have an odd one sided war with underscores. Avatar: 10/10 I'm a sucker for animated pixel things. Signature: 5/10 Not too bad, but the bottom array of banners could use some cleaning up. Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 Name: 6/10 I really wish the P in phoenix were capitalized and the double x is a bit distracting Avatar: 9/10 Gorgeous art! It's slightly blurry, though. Siggy: 10/10 Again, gorgeous art and so simple! <3 Please explain ratings ~ Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 (edited) N: 9/10 Nice! My main issue is the CamelCase... A: 10/10 Nice art. Who did it? S: 10/10 Cool animation - someone must've spent awhile on it! Your links are also neat and noticeable. -Pleae explain ratings, thanks. Edited August 28, 2016 by Dusky_Flareon Share this post Link to post
Posted August 28, 2016 Name - 7/10 - 4 points for Dusky (Favourite time of day and my old nickname was Dusk). 3 Points for Flareon because I like Flareon but they're not my favourite Eeveelution. Avatar - 8/10 - I like animated avatars, and I like dragons, so 4 points for each. Signature - 5/10 - Informative, but a little...bland, for me. Plus I find making it centre makes it look better (but that's just me). Share this post Link to post
Posted August 29, 2016 Name: 10/10, no real errors. Avatar: 4/10, kinda low quality. Signature: 9.999.../10, I like the way it looks. Share this post Link to post
Posted August 29, 2016 (edited) Name: 6/10 kinda long Avatar: 3/20 blurry and not really interesting Signature: 3/10 very cluttered and small hard to read. (My username is a character in a story I wrote. A bit of a pun [her being a Dragon princess] Angelwolf was the last name of her mate) Edited August 29, 2016 by AroaraAngelwolf Share this post Link to post
Recommended Posts